In yet another display of judicial obtuseness, Judge Andrew Keyser KC has quashed James Howells’s decade-long attempt to recover a £600 million bitcoin fortune lost in a Newport landfill. The judge ruled in favour of Newport City Council, striking out Howells’s claim with dismissive remarks about its “realistic prospects.”
The case revolved around Howells’s accidental disposal of a hard drive in 2013, which contained a bitcoin wallet now worth an estimated £600 million—or even £1 billion by next year, according to Howells. The computer expert had offered the council a share of the proceeds in exchange for permission to search the landfill, but his pleas have been consistently met with resistance.
Judge Keyser justified his decision by stating that Howells’s claim lacked reasonable grounds and was unlikely to succeed if it went to trial. However, critics might question whether this “reasoning” adequately considers the unique circumstances.
The council argued that the hard drive became their property once it entered the landfill, conveniently ignoring the glaring fact that its value lies not in its material form but in the digital assets it contains. The judge embraced this bureaucratic interpretation without probing the broader implications. Environmental concerns were also cited, though Howells proposed a “precise excavation” managed by expert teams, a solution seemingly ignored in favour of rigid adherence to permits.
Howells’s representation by pro bono lawyers highlights the systemic hurdles individuals face when taking on powerful institutions. Despite offering a logical plan and incentives, he found himself blocked at every turn by a council unwilling to negotiate and a judge too willing to rubber-stamp their position.
Internet and Multimedia expert, Jonathan Bishop, commented on the fiasco. “This decision totally lacking in merit not only denies justice to Mr. Howells but also squanders a golden opportunity for Newport City Council to benefit from a shared windfall that could have transformed the local community,” the former councillor said. “Mr. Howells has spent more than a decade seeking permission to recover the hard drive accidentally discarded in 2013.
“His proposals were reasonable, his plans detailed, and his offer of sharing the proceeds generous. Yet, Judge Keyser dismissed the case as having ‘no realistic prospect of succeeding.’”
“How could a carefully planned excavation, led by experts, be deemed so impractical as to warrant outright dismissal without even a trial?”
“With yet another rubbish decision, it is quite obvious that Judge Andrew Keyser is unfit for office and should resign.”
This is not the first questionable ruling from Judge Keyser, whose decisions often appear to favour institutional rigidity over pragmatic solutions. With Howells vowing to appeal, the public can only hope higher courts will take a more nuanced view. For now, Judge Keyser’s “rubbish decision” leaves one man’s fortune—and a potential windfall for Newport—rotting in a landfill.


