In a significant development in the case involving Councillor Jonathan Bishop, the Queen’s Bench Division of the Administrative Court has ruled in favour of his pursuit to ensure fair and just proceedings regarding allegations made against him.
The case revolves around complaints brought forward by fellow council members, alleging inappropriate behaviour, including the use of aggressive language, by Councillor Bishop. These complaints triggered an investigation by the Public Service Ombudsman for Wales, with authority invoked under the Local Government Act 2000 Pt III.
Councillor Bishop contended that these complaints should be resolved through the council’s established local resolution process, as per the procedure adopted in 2019. He argued that some of the complaints were rooted in interpersonal issues, and he raised concerns about perceived bias against him by the Ombudsman. Additionally, he noted that certain complaints pertained to his off-duty conduct. In response, he sought an injunction to pause the Ombudsman’s investigation.
Opposing the injunction, the Ombudsman asserted that there was no substantial issue to be litigated, and Councillor Bishop’s claims lacked merit.
The court’s ruling upheld the right of Councillor Bishop to seek fair proceedings. The application for an injunction was denied, with the court finding that Councillor Bishop had a valid argument regarding the appropriate resolution process for the complaints. While some complaints centred on issues related to politeness and language use, the court recognised that others carried more significant implications that could potentially harm the council’s reputation.
Addressing the allegation of bias against the Ombudsman, the court found that it lacked merit, as the Ombudsman had valid reasons for not investigating a previous complaint against the council chair. Furthermore, the court ruled that Councillor Bishop’s concerns regarding his off-duty conduct could be appropriately addressed during the ongoing Ombudsman’s investigation.
Additionally, Councillor Bishop had disclosed that he has autistic spectrum disorder and learning disabilities. The Ombudsman had acknowledged these conditions and promised to make reasonable accommodations. In light of these circumstances, the court concluded that there was no substantial issue to be tried, leading to the denial of the injunction.
The case continues as both parties navigate the investigation process, ensuring that all relevant concerns are addressed in a fair and impartial manner.

