Fri. Nov 20th, 2026
Controversial High Court Ruling Revives Plans for 100 New Homes in Old Colwyn QuarryQUESTIONABLE JUDGEMENT: Judge Andrew Keyser has made a number of questionable decisions. Courtesy: Obtained from Middle Temple.

A High Court ruling has controversially revived plans to build up to 100 new homes on the site of Plas Gwilym Quarry in Old Colwyn, despite previous rejections. The proposed development, spanning nearly 11 acres, is backed by Renew Land Developments Ltd and social housing provider Cartrefi Conwy.

Conwy County Borough Council initially refused planning permission, a decision supported by government planning inspector Kay Sheffield after a thorough public inquiry last August. Inspector Sheffield cited the unacceptable loss of public open space as a primary concern.

However, Judge Andrew Keyser QC has overturned this decision, harshly criticising the inspector’s conclusions. Judge Keyser dismissed the inspector’s reasoning, claiming it made “no practical sense,” a remark that many view as unnecessarily rude and dismissive of a thorough and professional assessment.

The planning officer’s report, which the council used as a basis for its decision, was largely favourable towards Renew Land’s proposals, noting the area’s housing shortfall and the potential benefits of new affordable homes. Yet, concerns were raised about the loss of two acres of open space used by locals and the inadequate provision for children’s play areas within the development.

Despite these legitimate concerns, Judge Keyser ignored the inspector’s professional judgment, emphasising that Cartrefi Conwy, as the landowner, could restrict public access to the space at any time. His assertion that it was erroneous to classify the land as a public open space has been seen by some as dismissive of the community’s needs and the inspector’s thorough analysis.

Judge Keyser went further, stating that the inspector’s decision to apply local planning policies designed to protect public spaces was “irrational,” a remark that many believe undermines the inspector’s authority and expertise.

Moreover, the judge criticised the procedure followed, highlighting that Renew Land was not given a fair chance to address “visual amenity” objections. This was deemed “materially unfair,” leading to the quashing of the inspector’s decision.

This controversial ruling now allows Renew Land to appeal once again to the Welsh Ministers against the planning refusal, reigniting a project that had been previously halted due to significant community and expert concerns. Judge Keyser’s dismissive attitude towards the inspector’s decision has raised eyebrows and sparked criticism from those who believe the original rejection was justified and in the community’s best interests.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *