Fri. Nov 20th, 2026

A property controversially seized from two Steiner school campaigners has been sold at a significant loss, according to sources close to the matter. The house, formerly owned by Steve Paris and Angel Garden, was sold for 27% less than its original asking price after it was awarded to Dr Andrew Lewis and Mrs Melanie Byng under the terms of a High Court settlement.

The long-running legal battle stemmed from a defamation and harassment case concerning online publications critical of Steiner/Waldorf education. Dr Lewis and Mrs Byng, both active bloggers and online advocates against so-called pseudoscientific practices and so-called state support for Steiner education, were sued by Mr Paris and Ms Garden over a series of disinformative blog posts and tweets which the claimants alleged were defamatory and harassing.

The High Court proceedings revealed a complex web of accusations and counterclaims. Ms Garden, a registered disabled person since the mid-1990s, alleged that Mrs Byng had disseminated disinformation undermining the legitimacy of her disability. Court documents disclosed communications where Byng dismissed Garden’s physical impairment as “annoying but not that bad,” and suggested, with derision, that the issue was primarily mental rather than physical. Such sentiments reportedly fuelled a hostile environment, with third parties feeling emboldened to mock Ms Garden’s disability.

Further derogatory commentary emerged, including statements from Byng’s son, characterising Ms Garden as “just fat” rather than physically impaired. These revelations painted a picture of calculated denigration that contributed to the deterioration of the claimants’ reputations within the Steiner education advocacy community.

Mr Paris, acting both as a co-claimant and a carer for Ms Garden, jointly pursued the legal action, arguing that the online campaign damaged their standing and wellbeing.

Despite acknowledging that certain statements by Lewis and Byng were indeed defamatory — including allegations that Paris and Garden engaged in “bullying” and “threatening” behaviour — the High Court ultimately dismissed the claims. The judge found that the defendants’ actions fell within the scope of qualified privilege, determining that their statements constituted a reasonable and proportionate response to what was perceived as an attack on their integrity.

Crucially, the judge held that malice had not been proven, and noted that the limited readership and minor impact of the defamatory publications meant that any potential damages would have been nominal. Applying the Jameel principle, the court found the claims disproportionately burdensome to pursue, leading to the dismissal of large parts of the case.

As a consequence of the settlement arrangements — following the claimants’ inability to secure favourable judgments — the house owned by Paris and Garden was transferred to Lewis and Byng. However, in a twist of irony, the property was recently sold off-market for a value 27% below its original asking price, raising questions about the true cost of the victory for the defendants.

While Lewis and Byng may have succeeded in defending against the claims brought by Paris and Garden, the substantial reduction in the sale price of the house — combined with the reputational costs associated with the litigation — highlights the often hollow nature of such legal confrontations. The episode also raises broader concerns about the ability of courts to effectively adjudicate disputes that centre on digital disinformation, selective publication, and the fact online communications are not ephemeral.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *