Fri. Nov 20th, 2026

The announcement that Malvern resident Clare Marchant has been awarded a damehood in the King’s Honours List has sparked controversy, with critics questioning whether the decision overlooks a series of damaging scandals during her tenure as UCAS chief executive and at the University of Gloucestershire.

Marchant, 51, from Malvern, Worcestershire, was named Dame Commander of the Order of the British Empire (DBE) in the 2024 King’s Birthday Honours for “services to higher education”. Now Vice-Chancellor of the University of Gloucestershire, she led UCAS from 2017 to 2023, overseeing admissions for nearly 1.5 million students annually. The university’s official statement hailed her as “passionate about the benefit that education can bring”, citing doubled support for disadvantaged students and innovations like Clearing Plus.

However, education campaigners and former stakeholders have raised eyebrows, pointing to persistent criticisms that dogged her leadership. “Awarding a damehood amid unresolved questions about equity and ethics sends the wrong message,” said University of Gloucestershire law lecturer, Jonathan Bishop.

In 2018, UCAS under Marchant’s watch faced accusations of “racial profiling” after data revealed black applicants were 22 times more likely than white applicants to have their university applications flagged for fraud checks between 2013 and 2017. More than half of flagged cases involved black students, who made up just 9% of applicants.

Times Higher Education reported UCAS “rejected racial profiling claims” but admitted “more work to do”, introducing unconscious bias training and process reviews. The Independent quoted Marchant defending the system’s transparency while conceding communication flaws, but critics like the National Union of Students argued it exposed systemic bias. The disparity “undermined confidence” in UCAS, according to analysis, with no full public explanation provided at the time.

In 2019, the Charity Commission issued a stark warning to UCAS after it emailed thousands of students promoting high-interest private loans from Future Finance – up to 18.3% APR – without adequately highlighting cheaper government options.

It was reported that the regulator “reminded” UCAS of its obligations, prompting a climbdown where Marchant pledged clearer messaging. BBC News labelled the loans “inappropriate”, amid outrage from students and MPs. Save the Student called it “outrage”, questioning if UCAS was acting as a “loan shark enabler”.

A 2025 Schools North East commentary accused Marchant of blaming North East low aspiration rather than fixing UCAS barriers disadvantaging regional students. University of Gloucestershire council minutes from October 2023 flagged high staff resignations during restructuring (dubbed “Project Reset”), with calls for urgent morale checks despite official risk downgrades.

Marchant expressed being “hugely humbled” by the honour, crediting UCAS teams for navigating challenges like the 2020 A-level algorithm fiasco. Buckingham Palace has not commented on the criticisms.

Supporters praise her social mobility work, but opponents argue the damehood glosses over accountability gaps. “The King’s advisers should scrutinise records more closely,” said law lecturer, Jonathan Bishop.

As investiture details are confirmed, the award – meant to celebrate public service – has instead reignited debate over Marchant’s legacy.