A scathing report by the Equality and Social Justice Committee of the Senedd has uncovered significant leadership failings within Welsh fire services, particularly pointing to the inadequacies of fire authorities.
The report, titled “Sound The Alarm,” highlights concerns over the appointment of Stuart Millington as interim Chief Fire Officer at South Wales Fire and Rescue Service. The committee described the response to these concerns as “defensive” and “troubling,” warning that it risked reinforcing negative perceptions among both staff and the public regarding senior management.
The inquiry, driven by “alarming findings” from the Culture Review of South Wales Fire and Rescue Service led by Fenella Morris KC, revealed widespread issues. In response, the Welsh Government has initiated independent reviews into North and Mid and West Wales Fire and Rescue Services as well.
One of the most critical points raised by the Morris review was the questionable effectiveness of the Fire and Rescue Authorities (FRAs). The Fire Officers’ Association testified that members of the South Wales FRA lacked the necessary skills for proper governance. The association reported that many members contributed little to meetings and were often confused by the content of the papers, rendering them incapable of providing essential strategic oversight.
The committee’s report calls for significant reforms in FRA operations, recommending a reduction in their size and the inclusion of experts in equality, diversity, and inclusion. It also expressed concerns about the appointment of Millington as interim Chief Fire Officer despite unresolved allegations of misconduct related to bullying.
“We found the lack of clarity and the defensive, bordering on dismissive, tone of several individuals responding to these concerns troubling. In our view, the questions surrounding the appointment have risked reinforcing some of the negative perceptions amongst staff and the public about senior management and the commitment to change,” the report stated.
The committee also noted receiving direct, though unofficial, representations from staff expressing a lack of confidence in the process, indicating that staff morale and trust in the leadership are seriously undermined.
To address these issues, the report recommends that the Welsh Government collaborate closely with Fire Commissioners to recruit individuals with external expertise for key posts, particularly those influencing organizational culture. This process should begin with the upcoming recruitment for a new Chief Fire Officer for South Wales.
Jenny Rathbone MS, Chair of the Equality and Social Justice Committee, emphasised the urgent need for change: “Fire service staff in Wales are being let down by the leaders responsible for the governance of the fire and rescue services, and we need urgent change to restore faith so all staff feel safe in the workplace. We urge the Welsh Government to take radical steps to strengthen the efficiency and effectiveness of the governance structure.”
Echoing these concerns, Fire Brigades Union general secretary Matt Wrack stated, “Chief fire officers and senior managers have presided over a situation in which those who speak out against bullying, harassment, and discrimination are silenced or victimised.”
The findings of the “Sound The Alarm” report underscore the necessity for immediate and significant reform within Welsh fire services to restore confidence and ensure a safe working environment for all staff.

