A copyright dispute has arisen during the Llantwit Fardre by-election after Conservative candidate Joel James objected to the use of two photographs in campaign material.
In an email sent to the agent of independent candidate Jonathan Bishop, Conservative candidate Joel James said the photographs were owned by him and had been used without permission. Joel James asked for distribution of the current leaflet to stop and requested confirmation that this would happen.
Joel James also asked for a future leaflet to include a clear correction acknowledging the alleged unauthorised use.
“I hope this can be resolved amicably,” he wrote, adding that he would consider escalating the matter and pursuing available legal remedies if distribution continued.
The photographs are understood to show Mr James alongside senior Conservative figures, including former cabinet minister Penny Mordaunt and Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch.
Jonathan Bishop’s agent replied that the leaflet had been published by Crocels News, LLC, which is based in Wilmington, Delaware. The publisher was reviewing the matter under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, and Freeman Bishop;s agent referred to protections for political expression under US and European law.
Crocels News, LLC has asked for details of the photographs concerned, evidence of ownership, and information about any alleged online use so that the matter can be reviewed. The publisher has not admitted liability or accepted that copyright infringement occurred.
The dispute concerns both the status of the photographs and the circumstances in which they were obtained and used. It has not been established publicly whether Joel James owns the copyright in both images, whether any permission was granted, or whether the campaign received the photographs from a source that authorised their use.
Photographs are generally capable of copyright protection, although the rights position can depend on authorship, employment, assignment, licensing, and the way in which the material was used.
Crocels News, LLC said its review would consider any distinction between any online material and the separate question of printed campaign literature circulated during the by-election.
The dispute comes as Joel James seeks election to Rhondda Cynon Taf Council in a five-way contest for Llantwit Fardre. The other candidates are independent Jonathan Bishop, Plaid Cymru’s Danny Lyn Crudge, Reform UK’s Lyndon Evans, and Welsh Labour’s Lloyd Watkins.
Joel James previously represented Llantwit Fardre on RCT Council and later served as a Conservative Member of the Senedd. He is also a community councillor in Efail Isaf.
Freeman Bishop has previously represented the ward at community level and is campaigning as an independent candidate. His published priorities include improvements to public rights of way, biodiversity, and community safety.
The copyright issue remains unresolved, and no finding of infringement has been made. The parties are now being asked to clarify ownership, permission, and the scope of any distribution before deciding whether further action is necessary.

