Fri. Nov 20th, 2026

A High Court ruling has drawn an important boundary around judicial discretion in costs, making clear that a party’s refusal to mediate or settle does not, without more, justify penalisation where it has otherwise engaged properly in dispute resolution.

In MJS Projects (March) Limited v RPS Consulting Services Limited, the court awarded interim costs of more than £300,000 to the defendant after rejecting the claimant’s attempt to displace the usual rule that costs follow the event. The claimant argued that the defendant’s refusal to mediate amounted to unreasonable conduct. The court disagreed.

Her Honour Judge Kelly, sitting in the High Court in Leeds, reaffirmed that the starting point remains unchanged: the unsuccessful party pays. Attempts to characterise a refusal to settle as inherently unreasonable were firmly rejected, with the court emphasising that litigation strategy cannot be second-guessed simply because one party declines a particular route to resolution.

Relying on Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust, the judgment underlined that mediation is not compulsory, nor is it the definitive benchmark of reasonable behaviour. A party is entitled to assess the strength of its case and decide whether settlement—at any stage—is appropriate. Refusing to mediate, or to accept settlement overtures, does not equate to a failure to engage in alternative dispute resolution.

In this case, the defendant had actively participated in the resolution process. It made multiple settlement offers, including a final offer of £200,000 shortly before trial. That conduct, the court held, demonstrated genuine engagement, even in the absence of mediation. The distinction is critical: refusing to settle is not the same as refusing to engage.

The court also recognised the practical and commercial realities surrounding mediation. With potential costs reaching £50,000, the defendant’s decision to await clarity on expert evidence before committing to mediation was neither obstructive nor unreasonable. Indeed, the court found that even if mediation had taken place, it would have had little prospect of success given the weakness of the claimant’s case.

Crucially, the judgment reinforces a principle that is often blurred in practice: parties are entitled to pursue litigation without fear of being penalised simply for standing their ground. The growing tendency to treat settlement—particularly mediation—as a quasi-obligation risks distorting both legal strategy and judicial reasoning.

This decision restores balance. It confirms that while courts may encourage resolution, they must not punish parties for declining it. Engagement in ADR is relevant; capitulation is not required.