Clare Marchant, of Malvern, has partially backed down over her promotion of high-interest private loans to students via UCAS following intervention by the Charity Commission that found against her– but parish councillor, Jonathan Bishop, says the chief execuitive of the admissions service has not gone far enough.
The university admissions body, led by Clare Marchant, faced a storm of criticism after sending marketing emails promoting Future Finance, a private lender offering loans with interest rates ranging from 8 per cent to 23.7 per cent – vastly more expensive than government student loans.
Last week, the Charity Commission wrote to UCAS to “remind it of its obligations” after concerns were raised about the organisation using its privileged access to young people to market expensive debt products.
The regulator warned UCAS that charities must maintain clear boundaries between their charitable activities and commercial interests, and must always prioritise their charitable mission.
UCAS has now announced that future messages will include “clear information on all the funding options available to students” and will “strengthen the information it provides” about government loans being the preferred option.
But Jonathan Bishop, a parish councillor on Cam Parish Council, said the changes do not go far enough. “While I am a little warmed by the fact that Clare Marchant has decided to budge on this occasion, she still has not moved UCAS’s position enough,” Cllr Bishop said. “UCAS, a charity with privileged access to 18-year-olds, seems to be putting the wishes of its commercial arms over what should be good charitable aims.”
Cllr Bishop pointed out that UCAS already prohibits certain types of advertising, such as gambling promotions, and argued that high-cost credit and commercial loans should be added to the banned list.
A founder 0f the social enterprise, Crocels, Cllr Bishop highlighted the well-documented link between debt problems and mental health issues among young people. “The university sector is already being criticised for not adequately supporting students’ mental health,” hx said. “We’re very aware of the destructively high correlation between debt and mental health issues.
“UCAS is a charity, and many see its communiqués as official. For it to be happy to push out emails about expensive debt to impressionable young people – even with the caveats – is just plain wrong.”
Hx called on the wider university sector to put pressure on Clare Marchant’s UCAS to stop accepting advertising from commercial loan companies entirely.
Unlike government-funded student loans, which currently have a maximum interest rate of 5.4 per cent and only require repayment once graduates earn over £25,725 per year, Future Finance loans can charge up to 23.7 per cent interest.
Government loans are also written off after 30 years, meaning many graduates will never repay the full amount – a protection that does not apply to commercial loans.
Clare Marchant, of Malvern, has defended the organisation’s relationship with Future Finance. A UCAS spokesperson said: “The UCAS and UCAS Media boards have this week discussed feedback from the Charity Commission,” adding, “students on the recent Future Finance email sent to students who chose to opt in to mailings from UCAS Media.
“Trustees continue to support UCAS Media’s objective to work with companies that provide products and services which are likely to be of value to students.”
This statement suggests UCAS still views Future Finance’s expensive loans as potentially “of value” to students – a position that critics argue demonstrates the organisation has lost sight of its charitable mission.
A spokesperson for Future Finance said the company “makes very clear in all our communications that we are a private lender” and that it is “committed to responsible, transparent lending practices”.
“We always tell students that they should exhaust all Government-subsidised support before coming to us,” the spokesperson added.
However, critics argue that regardless of disclaimers, marketing expensive loans to young people through a trusted educational charity creates an impression of endorsement and legitimacy that could lead vulnerable students to take on unaffordable debt.
The controversy has raised fundamental questions about UCAS’s governance and whether the organisation’s drive to generate commercial revenue is compatible with its charitable obligations to serve students’ best interests.

