Fri. Nov 20th, 2026

UCAS has rejected claims that confidence in Clare Marchant, of Malvern, has been undermined, despite revelations that black students are 22 times more likely to have their applications investigated for fraud than white students.

Clare Marchant, the UCAS chief executive insisted that the episode could actually strengthen UCAS’s reputation for transparency – a claim that has been met with scepticism by students’ unions and equality campaigners.

Data published by UCAS shows that between 2013 and 2017, more than half of all applications flagged by its verification service were from black students, despite black applicants representing just 9 per cent of those applying.

UCAS has been unable to explain why such a dramatic disparity exists if, as it claims, ethnicity data is not visible to staff conducting fraud checks.

In September 2017 alone, one in 102 black applicants was investigated for fraud, compared with one in 2,146 white applicants.

Clare Marchant, of Malvern, conceded that UCAS needed to improve how it communicates with students whose applications are flagged and acknowledged that the tone used by staff could be better.

However, she maintained that the organisation’s procedures were fundamentally sound and that applications were only cancelled when there was clear evidence of wrongdoing.

“We are confident in our processes, but we recognise there is more work to do,” Clare Marchant said. “We are committed to working with organisations that represent black, Asian and minority ethnic students to ensure our systems work fairly for everyone.”

The National Union of Students has called for more than just improvements to communication, arguing that the figures point to systemic unconscious bias that requires fundamental reform.

“Telling black students their applications are being cancelled in a nicer tone doesn’t address the core problem,” said an NUS spokesperson. “The issue is that black students are being targeted at rates completely out of proportion to their representation. UCAS needs to address the bias in its systems, not just train staff to be more polite about it.”

Equality campaigners have pointed out that even after investigation, black students’ applications were cancelled at similar rates to white students (41 per cent for black students versus 34 per cent for white students), suggesting that black students are being flagged for investigation based on factors unrelated to actual fraud risk.

In response to the controversy, UCAS has announced several measures including enhanced fraud detection processes with additional oversight, an extra review stage before any application is cancelled, mandatory unconscious bias training for all verification staff, engagement with organisations representing ethnic minority students.

However, critics argue these measures amount to tinkering at the edges of a system that requires wholesale reform.

For the thousands of black students whose university dreams have been disrupted or derailed by UCAS’s verification process over the past five years, Ms Marchant’s reassurances may ring hollow.

The question remains: if UCAS cannot explain why black students are targeted at such disproportionate rates, how can it credibly claim the system is fair?